Geography of Job Loss

Posted by Dan on October 17, 2009

Somewhat related to the arguments that the game industry is “recession proof” or at least “recession resistant”, a very interesting interactive map outlining job creation/loss over the past 5 years is circulating around the internet. When viewing this map, keep in mind that the game development industry is highly centralized in Southern California, Seattle, Austin, and to a lesser extent Boston — keep track of these locations while you’re watching the progress, and that the map represents areas by MSA (so suburbs are included in the metropolis they are tied to, for instance Cambridge would be tied to Boston).

If you look in the beginning, you’ll notice SoCal booming, as well as in Austin, with no major losses anywhere until the mega-red explosion from Katrina hitting New Orleans, but even there are no major losses. Up through the beginning of 2008, California begins shrinking, with losses starting to appear for the first times in SoCal (although ironically, the reverse is occurring in the Bay Area), but Texas and Seattle remain booming with tens of thousands of new jobs.

Then by mid-2008, the meltdown is in full swing. Starting in South Florida, SoCal, and Detroit, it quickly spreads over the next year to the entire nation. Interestingly enough, while in August 2008 Los Angeles was posting a -97,800 lost job rate for the previous 12 months and -20,000 in San Francisco, Austin was up by 18,100 jobs and Seattle was up by 17,200.

By November, that had turned into nearly -160,000 lost jobs in LA alone, while even Seattle was starting to feel the heat with -11,000 or so. Boston was down by nearly -20,000, and only Austin (as an industry hub) remained in the green.

Perhaps the most fascinating slide is the end, which looks like red nuclear explosions going off; but lets pay attention to what you CAN’T see on that last slide: Austin down by only -1,400 jobs that year (keeping in mind this is across ALL industries) compared to -240,000 in LA.

The website itself states “The animated map makes clear that this recession has not treated all regions equally.” Does this mean that Austin is a safe place to work to wait out the recession? That might not be a stretch of the imagination. Texas isn’t faced with nearly the same budget meltdowns as California, and aside from Houston and Dallas, hasn’t been hit with the same critical job loss that California has (though the site also notes that Texas remained solid in part due to a run-up in oil prices through 2008, and that the receding job growth in 2009 came from the energy and construction sectors.)

The time will come where development studios are going to have to think harder about where they set up shop — not just in terms of access to employment talent or favorable taxes, but economic solidity and risk of rampant unemployment in other critical sectors like public safety or education. Perhaps this map will highlight that for some studios.

Popularity: 12% [?]